Costs in Personal Injury Claims: Frequently Asked Questions

Contact Us Today

Sign up to our newsletter

Consent

Understanding legal costs in personal injury claims is important for both claimants and solicitors. The amount recoverable can vary considerably depending on the type of injury, the complexity of the case, the funding arrangement and the court rules that apply.

At ARC Costs, our qualified Costs Lawyers, trainee Costs Lawyers, experienced Costs Draftsmen and ACL Costs Paralegals assist with costs recovery in personal injury litigation, including complex and high-value catastrophic injury claims.

Below, we answer frequently asked questions about personal injury legal costs, funding arrangements and the assessment process.

What are Legal Costs in Personal Injury Claims?

Legal costs are the fees and expenses incurred when pursuing or defending a compensation claim.

These may include:

  • Solicitors’ professional fees.
  • Barristers’ fees.
  • Medical reports and expert witness fees.
  • Court fees.
  • Other necessary disbursements.
  • Certain insurance-related expenses.

Where a personal injury claim succeeds, the defendant may be required to pay some or all of the claimant’s recoverable legal costs. However, the amount payable depends on the applicable costs rules, any settlement agreement and the terms of the costs order.

How are Personal Injury Claims Funded?

Many personal injury claims are funded through a Conditional Fee Agreement (CFA), commonly known as a no win no fee agreement.

Under a CFA, the solicitor’s entitlement to payment depends on the outcome of the claim and the terms agreed with the client.

If the claim succeeds, the solicitor may recover their basic fees from the defendant, subject to the applicable costs regime. The client may also be responsible for a success fee.

Other funding options include legal expenses insurance, private funding and, in limited circumstances, legal aid.

What is a Success Fee?

A success fee is an additional charge payable to a solicitor under a qualifying CFA when the claim succeeds.

In most modern personal injury claims, the success fee cannot be recovered from the defendant and is instead payable by the claimant.

For many personal injury CFAs, the success fee is capped at 25% of specified damages for pain, suffering and loss of amenity and past financial losses, excluding future losses.

The precise calculation depends on the agreement and applicable regulations.

What are Disbursements in Personal Injury Claims?

Disbursements are expenses incurred in progressing litigation, often involving payments to third parties.

Examples include medical reports, expert witness fees, court fees and certain barristers’ fees.

Whether these expenses are recoverable depends on their necessity, reasonableness and the applicable costs provisions.

In cases governed by fixed recoverable costs, specific rules determine which disbursements can be claimed in addition to the fixed legal fees.

What is ATE Insurance?

After the Event (ATE) insurance is a policy obtained after a dispute has arisen. It may provide cover against certain financial risks associated with unsuccessful litigation, including adverse costs liabilities and specified disbursements.

ATE premiums are generally not recoverable from defendants in modern personal injury claims, although limited statutory exceptions exist, including certain clinical negligence expert report premiums. The scope of cover and payment obligations depend on the individual policy.

What is BTE Legal Expenses Insurance?

Before the Event (BTE) insurance is legal expenses cover arranged before a dispute arises.

It may be included within household, motor or other insurance policies.

Where available, BTE insurance can contribute towards legal representation and associated expenses. Claimants should check their existing policies before entering into alternative funding arrangements.

Do All Personal Injury Claims Go to Court?

No. Many personal injury claims settle through negotiation without requiring a final court hearing.

Some claims are resolved before proceedings are issued, while others settle after litigation has commenced.

Where the parties cannot agree liability or compensation, the court may need to determine the dispute.

The applicable costs regime can depend on whether proceedings have been issued and the stage at which settlement occurs.

What are the Different Court Tracks for Personal Injury Claims?

The court allocates defended personal injury claims to a track based on factors including value, complexity and the evidence required.

Small Claims Track

The small claims track generally provides limited recovery of legal costs.

The applicable personal injury thresholds differ according to the type of claim. For example, special rules apply to many road traffic accident whiplash claims.

Fast Track

The fast track generally deals with claims valued up to £25,000 that meet the relevant procedural criteria. Many fast-track personal injury claims are subject to fixed recoverable costs under CPR Part 45.

Intermediate Track

The intermediate track generally covers suitable claims valued between £25,000 and £100,000, subject to the applicable complexity and procedural requirements.

Fixed recoverable costs ordinarily apply, although exclusions and transitional provisions must be considered.

Multi-Track

The multi-track is used for higher-value or more complex litigation. Serious personal injury claims involving substantial future losses, multiple experts or complex liability issues are frequently allocated to this track.

In these cases, costs budgeting and detailed assessment can be particularly important. ARC Costs regularly assists with multi-track costs recovery and negotiations.

What Happens to Legal Costs if a Personal Injury Claim Succeeds?

Where a claimant succeeds, the defendant will often be responsible for paying recoverable legal costs. However, this does not necessarily mean that every fee incurred will be paid. In fixed recoverable costs cases, the relevant rules determine the recoverable amounts.

Where standard basis costs apply, the court considers whether the costs were reasonably incurred, reasonable in amount and proportionate.

Any difference between the costs incurred and those recovered may have implications for the claimant, depending on the funding agreement.

What Happens if a Personal Injury Claim Fails?

Personal injury claimants generally benefit from Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting (QOCS), which restricts the enforcement of defendants’ costs orders in qualifying proceedings.

QOCS does not prevent a defendant from obtaining a costs order, and enforcement may be permitted against certain damages, interest or costs recovered by the claimant.

Exceptions can also arise, including where a claim is found to be fundamentally dishonest.

Claimants should therefore understand their potential financial exposure and the terms of any CFA or ATE policy.

Why Are Costs Higher in Complex Personal Injury Claims?

Serious injury litigation often requires extensive preparation and specialist evidence. For example, a catastrophic injury claim may involve several medical experts, care assessments, rehabilitation evidence, employment records and calculations of future financial losses. These cases can continue for several years, generating substantial legal costs.

Accurate time recording, appropriate hourly rates and effective costs budgeting are essential to supporting recovery. Our catastrophic injury costs drafting service assists solicitors with these particularly demanding cases.

How Are Disputed Personal Injury Costs Assessed?

Where the parties cannot agree the amount of recoverable costs, the dispute may proceed to detailed assessment. The receiving party generally serves a Bill of Costs and Notice of Commencement.

The paying party ordinarily has 21 days to serve Points of Dispute, identifying the items challenged. The receiving party may then serve Points of Reply, and the parties can continue negotiating.

If settlement is not achieved, the court may determine the amount payable through provisional or detailed assessment.

How Can ARC Costs Assist With Personal Injury Legal Costs?

ARC Costs provides specialist costs services to solicitors handling personal injury claims throughout England and Wales.

Our services include:

  • Preparing electronic Bills of Costs.
  • Drafting and reviewing costs budgets.
  • Preparing Points of Dispute and Points of Reply.
  • Negotiating inter partes costs claims.
  • Advising on hourly rates, proportionality and recoverability.
  • Providing representation at detailed assessment hearings.

Our team includes Thomas Higginbottom, Costs Lawyer and Director, who specialises in inter partes costs disputes and negotiations, and Robert Collington, Costs Lawyer, who has over 15 years’ experience in legal costs.

We work with both receiving and paying parties, providing practical support with routine costs matters and complex, high-value litigation.

Discuss Your Personal Injury Costs Requirements

Whether you require assistance preparing a Bill of Costs, challenging an excessive claim or managing costs in complex personal injury litigation, ARC Costs can provide specialist support.

Our team can review your requirements, discuss the relevant documentation and provide a quotation.

Call 01204 397302 or email info@arccosts.co.uk to discuss your instruction.

Location

4 Bark Street East, Bolton, BL1 2BQ

01204 397302

info@arccosts.co.uk

Follow Us

About the author: Robert Collington

Robert Collington is an experienced Costs Lawyer with over 15 years of experience in the legal costs industry. Having qualified as a Costs Lawyer in 2020, Robert has developed extensive knowledge of costs law, civil procedure and the complexities involved in recovering and challenging legal costs.

His expertise encompasses costs budgeting, Bills of Costs, Points of Dispute, costs negotiations and detailed assessment proceedings. Robert has particular experience in dealing with complex and high-value costs disputes, where a thorough understanding of the Civil Procedure Rules, relevant case law and the principles of reasonableness and proportionality is essential.

Robert takes a practical and commercially focused approach to legal costs, recognising the importance of achieving favourable outcomes while minimising unnecessary expenditure and delays. His work involves considering both the technical and financial aspects of costs disputes, helping clients understand their position and the options available to them.

Through his articles for ARC Costs, Robert shares his knowledge of legal costs law, procedural developments and important court decisions, providing solicitors and other legal professionals with clear, accessible guidance on the issues affecting costs recovery and assessment.

Full profile: https://www.arccosts.co.uk/robert-collington-costs-lawyer/