Clinical Negligence Costs: Fixed Costs and CPR Rules
Contact Us Today
Clinical negligence costs have been a growing concern for the government, NHS and legal profession in recent years.
While fixed recoverable costs have been introduced across many areas of civil litigation, most clinical negligence cases remain exempt from these rules. However, the government has proposed changes to the way legal costs are recovered in lower-value claims.
We look at the current rules, when fixed costs apply and what solicitors should consider when recovering clinical negligence costs.
The Rising Cost of Clinical Negligence Claims
According to a National Audit Office report published in October 2025, the cost of settling clinical negligence claims in England increased from £1.1 billion in 2006–07 to £3.6 billion in 2024–25, after adjusting for inflation.
During the same period, claimant legal costs increased from £148 million to £538 million.
Although the number of claims has remained relatively stable across many medical specialities, the overall cost has continued to increase. Much of this increase is linked to high-value claims involving serious injuries and long-term care needs.
NHS Resolution has taken steps to resolve claims earlier and reduce the need for court proceedings. However, managing the cost of clinical negligence in England remains a challenge.
As part of its ten-year health plan, the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) has sought expert advice on how to manage the costs of clinical negligence and improve patients’ experiences of making a claim.
Do Fixed Recoverable Costs Apply to Clinical Negligence Cases?
In October 2023, the fixed recoverable costs regime was extended to cover many civil claims worth up to £100,000.
Under this regime, the amount of legal costs that a successful party can recover is largely determined by the value, complexity and stage of the claim, rather than the actual time spent by their solicitor.
However, most clinical negligence claims are excluded.
Under CPR 26.9(10)(b), a clinical negligence claim must normally be allocated to the multi-track unless:
- The claim would otherwise be suitable for the intermediate track.
- The defendant has admitted liability in full, including breach of duty and causation.
- The admission was made in the Letter of Response under the relevant Pre-Action Protocol.
Where these conditions are met, fixed recoverable costs may apply, subject to the other applicable rules.
If the defendant admits that negligent treatment occurred but disputes whether it caused the claimant’s injuries, the above requirements will not have been met.
Proposed Fixed Costs for Lower-Value Clinical Negligence Claims
The Department of Health and Social Care previously announced plans to introduce a separate fixed recoverable costs scheme for clinical negligence claims valued between £1,501 and £25,000.
The aim was to reduce legal costs, simplify the claims process and encourage earlier settlements.
The National Audit Office found that combined claimant and NHS legal costs for claims worth £25,000 or less were 3.7 times the amount of compensation awarded in 2024–25.
However, a lower-value clinical negligence claim is not necessarily a straightforward case. Solicitors may still need to obtain medical records, instruct independent experts and investigate whether negligent treatment caused an injury.
These investigations can be expensive, regardless of the amount of compensation awarded.
The proposed scheme was originally due to be introduced in April 2024. However, as of November 2026, it has not been implemented.
How Are Clinical Negligence Costs Recovered?
Where fixed recoverable costs do not apply, the amount of legal costs recoverable will depend on the costs order or settlement agreement.
Where costs are awarded on the standard basis, the costs claimed must be reasonable and proportionate under CPR 44.3.
Recoverable costs may include:
- Solicitors’ fees.
- Barristers’ fees.
- Medical expert fees.
- Court fees.
- Other necessary disbursements.
If costs cannot be agreed, the receiving party will generally prepare a Bill of Costs setting out the work undertaken and the amount claimed.
The paying party can challenge these costs by serving Points of Dispute.
If negotiations are unsuccessful, the matter may proceed to detailed assessment, where the court determines the amount payable.
Costs Budgeting in Clinical Negligence Cases
Many clinical negligence cases involve significant legal costs, particularly where multiple medical experts are required or the claimant has suffered life-changing injuries.
Where costs budgeting applies, solicitors must prepare a Precedent H costs budget setting out incurred and estimated future costs.
Accurate costs budgeting is important, as exceeding an approved budget can affect the amount ultimately recoverable.
Solicitors should regularly review their budgets and consider whether a budget variation is required if there is a significant development in the case.
Reducing Clinical Negligence Costs and Improving Patient Care
With increasing financial pressures across health and social care services, reducing unnecessary legal expenditure could help release funds to improve patient care.
However, any changes to costs recovery must also consider the impact on access to justice.
If fixed costs are set too low, solicitors may struggle to take on cases that require extensive medical investigations.
Improving patient safety, admitting liability earlier and encouraging settlement may help reduce the overall cost of claims without restricting access to legal representation.
How Can ARC Costs Assist With Clinical Negligence Costs?
ARC Costs regularly assists solicitors and law firms with clinical negligence costs, including complex and high-value claims.
Our team comprises qualified Costs Lawyers, trainee Costs Lawyers, experienced Costs Draftsmen and ACL Costs Paralegals.
Our services include costs budgeting, Bills of Costs, fixed recoverable costs advice, Points of Dispute, costs negotiations and detailed assessment.
Our team includes Thomas Higginbottom, Costs Lawyer and Director, who specialises in costs disputes and negotiations, and Robert Collington, Costs Lawyer, who has over 15 years of experience in legal costs.
For assistance recovering or challenging clinical negligence costs, contact ARC Costs on 01204 397302 or email info@arccosts.co.uk.
Follow Us
Robert Collington is an experienced Costs Lawyer with over 15 years of experience in the legal costs industry. Having qualified as a Costs Lawyer in 2020, Robert has developed extensive knowledge of costs law, civil procedure and the complexities involved in recovering and challenging legal costs.
His expertise encompasses costs budgeting, Bills of Costs, Points of Dispute, costs negotiations and detailed assessment proceedings. Robert has particular experience in dealing with complex and high-value costs disputes, where a thorough understanding of the Civil Procedure Rules, relevant case law and the principles of reasonableness and proportionality is essential.
Robert takes a practical and commercially focused approach to legal costs, recognising the importance of achieving favourable outcomes while minimising unnecessary expenditure and delays. His work involves considering both the technical and financial aspects of costs disputes, helping clients understand their position and the options available to them.
Through his articles for ARC Costs, Robert shares his knowledge of legal costs law, procedural developments and important court decisions, providing solicitors and other legal professionals with clear, accessible guidance on the issues affecting costs recovery and assessment.
Full profile: https://www.arccosts.co.uk/robert-collington-costs-lawyer/