MP Call for Review of Fundamental Dishonesty and QOCS Rules

Contact Us Today

Sign up to our newsletter

Consent

The House of Commons Justice Committee has called on the government to review the rules surrounding fundamental dishonesty in personal injury claims.

The recommendation follows concerns that some defendant solicitors may be using the threat of fundamental dishonesty allegations to discourage claimants from pursuing genuine compensation claims.

In its latest report on access to justice, the committee also called for a review of fixed recoverable costs and recommended extending Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting (QOCS) to other areas of litigation.

These recommendations could have a significant impact on personal injury solicitors, claimants and the legal costs sector.

Concerns Over Fundamental Dishonesty Allegations

Fundamental dishonesty rules were introduced to prevent fraudulent and deliberately exaggerated personal injury claims.

While these rules play an important role in tackling dishonest claims, claimant solicitors have raised concerns about how they are being used by some defendants.

There are concerns that allegations of fundamental dishonesty are being made even where there is limited evidence of dishonesty.

If a claimant is found to have been fundamentally dishonest, they could lose their compensation and be required to pay the defendant’s legal costs.

For many claimants, the possibility of having to pay thousands of pounds in legal fees may be enough to discourage them from continuing with an otherwise genuine claim.

The Justice Committee has acknowledged these concerns and recommended that the government review the rules to determine whether there are sufficient safeguards against unreasonable conduct by defendants.

What Is Fundamental Dishonesty Under Section 57?

Section 57 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 sets out what happens when a personal injury claimant is found to have been fundamentally dishonest.

Under Section 57, where a claimant is entitled to compensation but is found to have been fundamentally dishonest in relation to their claim or a related claim, the court must dismiss the entire claim unless doing so would cause substantial injustice.

This means that even if a claimant has suffered a genuine injury, they could lose their entitlement to compensation if they have been dishonest about a significant part of their claim.

Examples of fundamental dishonesty may include:

  • Deliberately exaggerating the severity of an injury.
  • Providing false information about loss of earnings.
  • Claiming for care or assistance that was not required.
  • Providing false evidence about how an accident occurred.
  • Deliberately misleading medical experts about symptoms.

However, making a genuine mistake or providing inconsistent information does not automatically mean that a claimant has been fundamentally dishonest.

The purpose of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act 2015 is to prevent dishonest claims, rather than penalise claimants for genuine errors.

How Does Fundamental Dishonesty Affect Legal Costs?

Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting (QOCS) was introduced in April 2013 to reduce the financial risks associated with making a personal injury claim.

Under QOCS, there are restrictions on how much of a defendant’s legal costs can be enforced against a claimant.

This provides individuals with a degree of financial protection when pursuing compensation.

However, there are exceptions to these rules.

Under CPR 44.16, where a claim is found to be fundamentally dishonest, the defendant may obtain permission from the court to enforce their costs order in full.

Depending on the complexity of the case and how far proceedings have progressed, these costs can be substantial.

It is important to remember that an allegation of fundamental dishonesty alone does not remove QOCS protection. The court must make a finding of fundamental dishonesty before this exception applies.

Can Legal Costs Be Challenged Following a Finding of Fundamental Dishonesty?

Even where a claimant has been found to be fundamentally dishonest, this does not necessarily mean that they must pay every amount claimed by the defendant.

Where a claim is dismissed under Section 57 of the Criminal Justice and Courts Act, the court must record the amount of compensation the claimant would have received had the claim not been dismissed.

This amount must be deducted from the costs that the court would otherwise order the claimant to pay.

Where legal costs are subject to assessment, the claimant may also be able to challenge the amounts claimed by the defendant.

Common grounds for challenging legal costs include:

  • Excessive solicitors’ hourly rates.
  • Unreasonable time spent on legal work.
  • Duplication of work.
  • Unnecessary expert fees or disbursements.
  • Disproportionate costs, where the standard basis of assessment applies.

A costs specialist can review the defendant’s Bill of Costs, prepare Points of Dispute and negotiate a reduction in the amount payable.

If costs cannot be agreed, the matter may proceed to detailed assessment.

Could QOCS Be Extended to Other Types of Claims?

The Justice Committee has also recommended that the government consider extending QOCS to discrimination and abuse claims brought in the County Court or High Court.

The committee questioned why individuals pursuing personal injury claims receive costs protection while those pursuing other types of civil claims do not.

An individual making a discrimination claim, for example, may face significant legal costs if their claim is unsuccessful. This financial risk may prevent them from pursuing a genuine case.

The report also raised concerns about access to justice in other areas, including non-medical professional negligence and judicial review.

Extending QOCS could make it easier for individuals to pursue claims without facing the same level of financial risk.

However, no changes to the rules have been made as a result of these recommendations at this stage.

MPs Call for a Review of Fixed Recoverable Costs

Alongside its recommendations on fundamental dishonesty and QOCS, the Justice Committee has called for a review of fixed recoverable costs.

Under the fixed recoverable costs regime, the amount of legal costs that can be recovered is generally determined by the value, complexity and stage of the claim.

However, there are concerns that the amounts recoverable do not always reflect the actual cost of conducting litigation.

The Association of Personal Injury Lawyers (APIL) welcomed the committee’s recommendations, highlighting that inflation had increased by 42% since 2013, while recoverable legal costs for many injured people had remained unchanged.

With increasing salaries, running costs and other business expenses, some law firms may find it increasingly difficult to take on certain types of personal injury claims.

The committee has recommended that fixed recoverable costs are reviewed regularly to ensure that they reflect the cost of providing legal services.

It has also called for greater clarity on whether fixed recoverable costs should apply to housing claims.

Concerns Over Clinical Negligence Costs Reforms

The Justice Committee also questioned whether introducing a no-fault compensation scheme for clinical negligence claims would benefit patients or reduce costs.

Clinical negligence claims often require detailed investigations and medical expert evidence, regardless of the amount of compensation being claimed.

Any changes to the way clinical negligence claims are handled must therefore consider both the cost of litigation and the ability of injured patients to access legal advice and representation.

What Do These Recommendations Mean for Law Firms?

The committee’s report highlights growing concerns about the impact of legal costs rules on access to justice.

A review of fundamental dishonesty rules could introduce greater safeguards against unsupported allegations, while a review of fixed recoverable costs could help address concerns about the financial viability of lower-value claims.

For now, the existing Civil Procedure Rules continue to apply. Law firms should monitor the government’s response and any proposed changes to the costs rules.

How Can ARC Costs Assist?

ARC Costs provides specialist legal costs services to solicitors and law firms across England and Wales.

Our team includes qualified Costs Lawyers, trainee Costs Lawyers, experienced Costs Draftsmen and ACL Costs Paralegals.

Thomas Higginbottom, Costs Lawyer and Director, specialises in inter partes costs disputes, Points of Dispute and costs negotiations.

We assist both receiving and paying parties with personal injury costs, including costs disputes arising from findings of fundamental dishonesty.

Our services include preparing Bills of Costs, drafting Points of Dispute, calculating fixed recoverable costs, negotiating settlements and providing representation at detailed assessment hearings.

For assistance with a legal costs dispute, contact ARC Costs on 01204 397302 or email info@arccosts.co.uk.

Location

4 Bark Street East, Bolton, BL1 2BQ

01204 397302

info@arccosts.co.uk

Follow Us

About the author: Robert Collington

Robert Collington is an experienced Costs Lawyer with over 15 years of experience in the legal costs industry. Having qualified as a Costs Lawyer in 2020, Robert has developed extensive knowledge of costs law, civil procedure and the complexities involved in recovering and challenging legal costs.

His expertise encompasses costs budgeting, Bills of Costs, Points of Dispute, costs negotiations and detailed assessment proceedings. Robert has particular experience in dealing with complex and high-value costs disputes, where a thorough understanding of the Civil Procedure Rules, relevant case law and the principles of reasonableness and proportionality is essential.

Robert takes a practical and commercially focused approach to legal costs, recognising the importance of achieving favourable outcomes while minimising unnecessary expenditure and delays. His work involves considering both the technical and financial aspects of costs disputes, helping clients understand their position and the options available to them.

Through his articles for ARC Costs, Robert shares his knowledge of legal costs law, procedural developments and important court decisions, providing solicitors and other legal professionals with clear, accessible guidance on the issues affecting costs recovery and assessment.

Full profile: https://www.arccosts.co.uk/robert-collington-costs-lawyer/