Judge Dismisses Costs Appeal in Decade-Long Boundary Dispute
Contact Us Today
A High Court judge has dismissed a costs appeal in a boundary dispute that has lasted for a decade and reportedly resulted in one party spending more than £1 million in legal costs.
The case of Mary Egan v Neil Morgan & Anor [2026] EWHC 2946 (BP) involved a relatively small strip of land with little financial or practical value.
The judgment highlights the importance of proportionality, effective costs management and the wide discretion given to judges when making costs orders.
Background to the Boundary Dispute
The parties had been involved in litigation since 2016 over approximately 45 square metres of land along a 60-metre boundary.
The land, which consisted of grass, scrub and trees, was described by Mr Justice Tappin as having extremely limited value, if any.
Despite this, the appellant, Mary Egan, claimed to have spent more than £1 million in legal costs. The respondents had also incurred a six-figure sum in costs, despite representing themselves for much of the litigation.
In an earlier judgment in 2022, Recorder Dagnall commented on how boundary disputes can result in an expenditure of time, money and energy that bears little relationship to the value of the land in dispute.
The latest appeal concerned a costs order relating to a hearing that had taken place in 2017.
Why Was the Costs Order Appealed?
The original costs order required the respondents to pay one third of the appellant’s costs of the 2017 hearing.
The appellant sought to have this order set aside and replaced with an order requiring the respondents to pay her costs on the indemnity basis.
One of the grounds of appeal concerned the original judge’s conclusion that neither party had achieved an overall victory in the relevant litigation.
The appellant also argued that the conduct of the first respondent, including the use of abusive language towards legal professionals and court staff, should have resulted in a different costs order.
However, Mr Justice Tappin dismissed the appeal.
Although he acknowledged that abusive language towards lawyers, judges and court staff was unacceptable, he was not satisfied that the original judge had made an error that justified overturning the costs order.
He also concluded that the original judge was in the best position to assess the respondent’s conduct.
When Can a Costs Order Be Appealed?
Under CPR 44.2, the court has discretion over whether legal costs are payable, the amount payable and when they must be paid.
Although the general rule is that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs, the court can make a different order depending on the circumstances of the case.
When deciding what costs order to make, the court may consider:
-
The conduct of all parties before and during proceedings.
-
Whether a party has succeeded on part of its case, even if it has not been wholly successful.
-
Whether it was reasonable to raise or contest particular issues.
-
Whether a successful party has exaggerated its claim.
-
Relevant settlement offers made during proceedings.
The court may decide that one party should pay only a percentage of the other party’s legal costs, or the costs relating to a particular issue or period of litigation.
Appealing a costs order can be difficult because the original judge has considerable discretion when making their decision.
Simply disagreeing with the outcome is unlikely to provide sufficient grounds for a successful appeal. The appellant will generally need to demonstrate that the judge made an error of principle, took irrelevant factors into account or reached a decision outside the reasonable scope of their discretion.
Standard Basis and Indemnity Basis Costs
An important aspect of the appeal was the appellant’s request for an indemnity basis costs order.
Under CPR 44.3, legal costs can be assessed on either the standard basis or the indemnity basis.
Standard Basis Costs
When costs are assessed on the standard basis, the court will only allow costs that are reasonably incurred, reasonable in amount and proportionate.
Where there is doubt about whether costs are reasonable or proportionate, that doubt will be resolved in favour of the paying party.
This means that even where legal work was reasonably necessary, the amount recoverable may still be reduced if the overall costs are considered disproportionate.
Indemnity Basis Costs
An indemnity basis costs order is generally more favourable to the receiving party.
Although costs must still be reasonably incurred and reasonable in amount, the same proportionality test does not apply. Any doubt about reasonableness is resolved in favour of the receiving party.
Indemnity costs may be awarded where a party’s conduct takes the case outside the ordinary course of litigation or in other circumstances that justify such an order.
However, unreasonable or unacceptable conduct does not automatically entitle the opposing party to indemnity costs.
The decision in this boundary dispute demonstrates the discretion available to the court when considering whether an indemnity basis costs order is appropriate.
The Importance of Proportionality in Legal Costs
The amount reportedly spent in this case raises wider questions about the proportionality of legal expenditure in property and boundary disputes.
Under CPR 44.3(5), costs are proportionate if they bear a reasonable relationship to:
-
The sums in issue in the proceedings.
-
The value of any non-monetary relief sought.
-
The complexity of the litigation.
-
Any additional work caused by the conduct of the paying party.
-
Wider factors involved in the proceedings, such as reputation or public importance.
-
Additional work or expense arising from the vulnerability of a party or witness.
Boundary disputes can involve complex legal issues, historic property documents, surveyor reports and expert evidence. The financial value of the land is therefore not the only factor when considering proportionality.
Nevertheless, where legal costs significantly exceed the value of what is being disputed, there can be a substantial risk that those costs will not be recovered in full if assessed on the standard basis.
It is important to distinguish between the legal costs a party incurs and the amount they are ultimately entitled to recover from their opponent.
Obtaining a favourable judgment or costs order does not guarantee full costs recovery.
How Can Solicitors Manage Costs in Boundary Disputes?
Early costs management is particularly important in property disputes, where the costs of litigation can quickly exceed the financial value of the claim.
Where costs budgeting applies, preparing an accurate Precedent H costs budget can help solicitors identify anticipated expenditure and manage the costs of proceedings.
Regular reviews of incurred and estimated costs can also help clients understand their financial position as litigation progresses.
Solicitors should consider the potential benefits of mediation, negotiated settlements and appropriate settlement offers throughout proceedings.
Early involvement from a legal costs specialist can help identify potential issues with costs recovery, assess financial exposure and provide guidance on whether anticipated expenditure is likely to be proportionate.
This is particularly important in longstanding disputes, where continued litigation can result in substantial costs liabilities for both parties.
Recovering and Challenging Legal Costs in Property Disputes
ARC Costs assists solicitors and law firms with legal costs arising from boundary disputes, property litigation and other complex civil disputes.
Our team includes qualified Costs Lawyers, trainee Costs Lawyers, experienced Costs Draftsmen and ACL Costs Paralegals.
We assist both receiving and paying parties with:
-
Costs budgeting and budget variations.
-
Preparation of Bills of Costs.
-
Preparing Points of Dispute and Points of Reply.
-
Reviewing the reasonableness and proportionality of legal costs.
-
Detailed assessment proceedings and advocacy.
Our team includes Thomas Higginbottom, Costs Lawyer and Director, who specialises in inter partes costs disputes and negotiations, and Robert Collington, Costs Lawyer, who has over 15 years of experience in legal costs.
Whether you require assistance recovering legal costs following successful litigation or challenging an excessive Bill of Costs, ARC Costs can help.
Contact our team today on 01204 397302 or email info@arccosts.co.uk.
Follow Us
Robert Collington is an experienced Costs Lawyer with over 15 years of experience in the legal costs industry. Having qualified as a Costs Lawyer in 2020, Robert has developed extensive knowledge of costs law, civil procedure and the complexities involved in recovering and challenging legal costs.
His expertise encompasses costs budgeting, Bills of Costs, Points of Dispute, costs negotiations and detailed assessment proceedings. Robert has particular experience in dealing with complex and high-value costs disputes, where a thorough understanding of the Civil Procedure Rules, relevant case law and the principles of reasonableness and proportionality is essential.
Robert takes a practical and commercially focused approach to legal costs, recognising the importance of achieving favourable outcomes while minimising unnecessary expenditure and delays. His work involves considering both the technical and financial aspects of costs disputes, helping clients understand their position and the options available to them.
Through his articles for ARC Costs, Robert shares his knowledge of legal costs law, procedural developments and important court decisions, providing solicitors and other legal professionals with clear, accessible guidance on the issues affecting costs recovery and assessment.
Full profile: https://www.arccosts.co.uk/robert-collington-costs-lawyer/